Mastering landing page A/B testing: A guide for success

In content marketing, the ability to make informed decisions based on data can set you apart from your competitors. 

Testing, and specifically A/B testing, is a simple yet profoundly useful tool for companies seeking to adopt this kind of data-driven, decision-making strategy. And one of the most impactful things to test is your landing page. 

In this guide, we’re going to look at the importance of landing page A/B testing — and examine some of the most common landing page variables to test. 

Whether you're a beginner dipping your toes into digital marketing, or a veteran looking to fine-tune your strategies to better appeal to your target audience, this comprehensive guide is packed with valuable insights and tactics to help you ace your A/B-testing efforts, and build successful landing pages. 

Let’s dive into landing page testing.

Why landing page A/B testing is important

• Improves conversion rate: The primary objective of A/B testing is to identify changes that increase or maximize an outcome of interest, also known as a conversion. Conversions could mean increased email newsletter sign-ups, clicks of a call-to-action (CTA) button, or even increased purchases.

• Reduces bounce rate: By testing different elements on your landing page, you can determine what content keeps visitors engaged longer, and reduce the number of people who leave (bounce) without taking action.

• Eliminates guesswork: Instead of making changes based on hunches, A/B testing provides data-backed results, allowing you to make more informed decisions about what works best for your audience.

• Increases user engagement: Understanding what appeals to your users can lead to a better user experience, which in turn can increase engagement and loyalty.

• Increases cost-effectiveness: A/B testing can save resources by helping you avoid unnecessary changes that might not yield results, or that could even be detrimental to the user experience.

• Enhances SEO efforts: Improved user engagement and lower bounce rates can have a positive impact on your site's SEO, potentially increasing your organic rankings.

• Supports continuous improvement: A/B testing encourages an ongoing process of testing, learning, and improvement, fostering a culture of continuous optimization.

• Informs other marketing efforts: Insights gained from A/B testing your landing pages can be applied to other aspects of your marketing strategy, such as email campaigns or social media advertising.

1. Headlines and copy

Headlines are the equivalent of first impressions. They're the first thing your audience sees on your landing page, and they can make or break whether a visitor decides to engage with your content. That's why A/B testing your headlines is so vital for optimizing your conversions.

• Increased engagement: By determining which headline types your audience responds to, you can tailor headlines to grab their attention and draw them into your content.

• Improved SEO: A/B tests that reveal certain keywords or phrases in your landing page headlines lead to better engagement and can also improve your search engine rankings.

• Higher conversions: Ultimately, more engaging headlines can lead to increased traffic, a lower bounce rate, and a higher conversion rate — as more visitors are drawn into your content and encouraged to take action.

The idea behind headline A/B testing is simple: you create two (or more) versions of a headline for the same piece of content — be it a product page, blog post, landing page, or any other part of your website. Half of your audience sees one headline (Version A), while the other half sees the other (Version B).

2. Layout

Landing pages are the gateway to your business for most visitors. They can be the deciding factor between users bouncing, or converting into leads or customers. Hence, optimizing your landing page layout through A/B testing can often have a significant impact on your conversion rate. 

• Better user experience: By understanding which landing page layout elements your audience prefers, you can create a more user-friendly and engaging landing page.

• Increased conversions: A well-optimized landing page can significantly boost your conversion rate by motivating more visitors to take the desired action.

• Lower bounce rates: If your A/B test reveals that a certain landing page layout keeps visitors on your page longer, this can reduce your bounce rate and potentially improve your search engine ranking.

The premise behind landing page layout A/B testing is to experiment with different design elements on a landing page — which could be anything from the placement of your CTA button, its color scheme, the type of images used, or even font size. You test to find the layout that resonates more with users and prompts them to take the desired action — signing up for a newsletter, requesting a quote, making a purchase, downloading an ebook, and so on.

3. Product images and descriptions

Product images and descriptions play a crucial role in online shopping because they provide customers with a visual representation of what they're buying. With that in mind, A/B testing different product images and descriptions on your landing page can help optimize marketing campaigns for clicks and sales.

• Improved click-through rates: By determining which product images are more appealing to viewers, you can optimize your campaigns to generate more clicks.

• Increased sales: If your A/B test reveals that certain images lead to higher sales, you can use that insight to enhance your product listings to drive more purchases.

• Enhanced user experience: Understanding what type of product images resonate with your audience can improve their shopping experience on your site, potentially leading to higher customer satisfaction and loyalty.

Landing page A/B testing enables brands to experiment with different types of product images or descriptions — such as different angles, backgrounds, and lighting conditions, or products featured in use vs. in isolation.

4. CTA buttons

CTA buttons are crucial content elements that can guide users toward conversion, and typically guide visitors toward a desired action, such as "Buy now," "Sign up," "Download,” and so on. 

• Increased conversions: By determining which CTA button attributes lead to higher click-through rates (CTR), you can optimize your buttons to drive more conversions.

• Improved user experience: A/B tests can reveal that certain button designs, sizes, or colors are more appealing to users, and so enhance the overall user experience on your site.

• Better understanding of user behavior: The results of your A/B tests can provide valuable insights into your audience's preferences and behavior, helping you make more informed, data-driven design decisions in the future.

Optimizing CTA buttons through A/B testing can significantly impact your website's performance. The idea behind CTA button A/B testing is to experiment with different aspects of the button — be that its design, size, color, or text — and gauge which variation drives more conversions.

5. Testimonials and social proofs

Customer testimonials are a powerful trust-building tool, and can influence purchasing decisions. A/B testing the placement and design of testimonials, and other types of social proofs, can significantly impact your conversion rates.

• Increased trust: By determining the optimal placement and design for your testimonials, you can make them more noticeable and convincing to visitors, thereby increasing trust in your brand.

• Improved conversion rates: A/B tests may reveal that certain testimonial placements or designs lead to higher conversion rates, thereby helping you optimize your product pages to drive more sales.

• Enhanced user experience: Understanding what type of testimonials (text, video, etc.) and designs appeal to your audience can enhance overall user experience on your site.

Customer testimonial A/B testing involves experimenting with the placement, design, format (text, video, etc.) of testimonials, or even the number of testimonials displayed on a page, in order to see which variable encourages more conversions.

6. Forms

Forms are a critical component of many landing pages, and serve as a portal through which visitors transform into leads, subscribers, and customers. Digital forms have numerous purposes, including getting visitors to subscribe to newsletters, register for webinars, enter contact information, or submit purchase orders. With that in mind, optimizing your forms using A/B testing can be instrumental in enhancing conversion rates.

• Optimized user experience: By discovering which content elements your audience responds to, you can design a more user-centric and engaging form.

• Boosted conversions: A finely tuned form can significantly increase conversion rates by encouraging more visitors to complete and submit.

• Lower form abandonment rates: If an A/B test reveals that a particular form design or layout encourages users to fill it out completely, you may be able to decrease your form abandonment rate and potentially boost conversions and revenue.

As part of an A/B testing process, you’ll experiment with landing page forms by adjusting certain variables. Those might include the number of fields on the form, the language used in prompts, the color or size of the “submit” button, and even the wording or placement of the privacy statement.

How to A/B test landing pages

1. Identify your goal

Identifying your goal is the first and perhaps the most crucial step in A/B testing as a means to optimize landing page performance. It sets the direction for your entire test and determines the metrics you need to track.

In the context of landing pages, testing goals typically revolve around user engagement and conversion metrics. For instance, you might want to increase the number of visitors who fill out a form (landing page conversions), reduce the number of people who leave your page without interacting (landing page bounce rate), or improve the amount of time users spend on your page.

An A/B test objective should be specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART). For example, rather than simply aiming to "increase conversions," a SMART goal would be "to increase the conversion rate by 15% over the next quarter."

Having a clear goal not only helps you focus your testing efforts but also makes it easier to measure the success of the test. Your goal will guide the changes you make, influence which variant you choose as the winner, and ultimately determine whether the test has brought you closer to your broader business objectives.

Remember, the goal of A/B testing isn't just to figure out which version "wins." It's to learn more about your audience and their preferences so that you can provide a better user experience and drive more conversions in the long run.

2. Determine what to test

Determining what to test is a critical step in the A/B testing process. It involves deciding which elements on your landing page you will change in your variant version in order to determine whether it performs better than the control version.

The choice of test elements should be driven by your testing goal. If your goal is to increase conversions, for example, you might want to test elements that directly influence user decisions, like the CTA button, form fields, or the headline. 

3. Create a hypothesis

Creating a hypothesis is an essential part of the A/B testing process. A hypothesis is a proposed explanation or prediction based on limited evidence, which will be further investigated during the test.

In the context of A/B testing landing pages, your hypothesis should be a clear, concise statement that predicts the expected outcome of the test. It should specify the change you're making, the impact you expect this change to have, and a rationale for why you expect this result.

For example, the hypothesis "Changing CTA button color from blue to green will increase CTR by 10%" suggests that altering the color of the call-to-action (CTA) button to green could make it more noticeable or appealing to visitors, leading to a higher CTR.

It's important to note that a good hypothesis should not only predict the outcome but also be measurable and testable. In the above example, "increase click-through rates by 10%" is a measurable outcome that can be directly tested.

Establishing a clear hypothesis is beneficial for several reasons:

Focus: Your hypothesis helps keep your test focused on one particular element and outcome, preventing you from getting sidetracked by other factors.

Purpose: Your hypothesis will give your test a clear purpose, helping you and your team understand exactly what you're trying to achieve.

Analysis: Post-test, your hypothesis simplifies the analysis of results. You'll be able to clearly see if the results support or contradict your hypothesis.

4. Set up and run your A/B test

Setting up and running your A/B test is the action phase of the testing process. This phase involves creating different versions of your landing page and comparing them directly. You’ll have the current version (also known as the "control") and modified versions (the "variants"). Changes introduced in a variant should be based on the hypothesis you have formulated.

Most A/B testing tools allow you to easily create versions and split your traffic in order to compare them against the control. It's crucial to divide your traffic equally between the control and the variant to ensure a fair test. This means that 50% of your visitors will see the original version, and 50% will see the modified version.

Equally important is ensuring that each visitor only sees one version of the page during the test. This is to avoid confusing your visitors if they return to your page and see a different version. Most A/B testing tools automatically handle this through the use of cookies.

Once the test is set up, you need to let it run for a sufficient amount of time to collect enough data. The duration of an A/B test can vary depending on your website traffic, the magnitude of the change, the desired effect size, and the statistical significance level you want to achieve. Generally, a period of at least two weeks is recommended, but it could be longer for websites with lower traffic.

Statistical significance is a critical concept in A/B testing. It's a measure of the likelihood that the difference in performance between control and variant is not attributable to random chance. A common threshold for significance is 95%, meaning that there's a 5% chance that the observed difference could be due to chance.

Remember: it's essential not to stop the test too early, even if you see promising results. Ending a test prematurely can lead to inaccurate results and misguided decisions.

5. Analyze the results

Analyzing results is the next step in the landing page A/B testing process. After running the test for a sufficient amount of time, and achieving statistical significance, it's time to examine the collected data and draw conclusions.

Analysis should focus on comparing the performance of the control and variant versions of your landing page in relation to your initial goal. For instance, if your goal was to increase CTR, you will want to compare the CTR of both versions.

• Check the statistical significance: First, ensure that you've been able to achieve statistically significant results from your test. This means that the difference in performance between the two versions is unlikely to have occurred by chance. As mentioned earlier, a commonly applied threshold for statistical significance is 95%.

• Compare key metrics: Next, look at the key metrics related to your goal. If your goal was to increase conversions, compare the conversion rates of the control and variant landing pages.

• Understand the impact: Try to understand why the winning version performed better. Did the change you made resonate more with your audience? Or did it make the call-to-action more noticeable? Understanding the why behind results can provide valuable insights for future tests.

• Document your findings: Record the details of the test including your hypothesis, the changes made, the duration of the test, and the results. This documentation can serve as a valuable resource for future testing and decision-making.

Remember, even if your variant doesn't outperform the control, there's still value in the test. Negative results can help you understand what doesn't work for your audience — which is just as important as knowing what does work.

6. Implement the winning version

Implementing the winning version is the final action step in the landing page A/B testing process. After analyzing the results and determining a clear winner, you’ll need to implement the more successful version on your landing page.

If the variant (the version with changes) significantly outperforms the control (the original version), you’ll have clear evidence that the changes made have positively impacted the desired metric — whether that's CTR, conversion rate, time spent on page, or another key performance indicator. You should replace the existing landing page with the winning variant to benefit from its improved performance.

Not all tests will produce a clear winner. If there's no significant difference in performance between the control and the variant, or if the variant performs worse than the control, it doesn't mean the test was a failure. In fact, you should use the insights gained to formulate a new hypothesis for a fresh test. 

Remember, A/B testing is not a one-time activity but an ongoing process of continuous improvement. It's about learning from each test (successful or not), and using those learnings to make data-driven decisions and improvements.

In other words, there's always room for more testing and optimization. There may be, for example, other elements on your landing page that could be optimized, or the winning variant itself could potentially be improved further.

The continuous process of A/B testing can be broken down into four main steps: developing a hypothesis, testing that hypothesis, analyzing the results, and then implementing changes based on those results. After implementing the changes, the cycle starts again with a new hypothesis. 

1. Continual improvement: Even small changes can have a significant impact on your conversion rates. By continually testing and optimizing, you can make incremental improvements that add up over time.

2. Changing user behavior: User behavior and preferences can change over time due to factors like technology trends, market conditions, and competitor actions. Regular testing allows you to stay in tune with these changes and adjust your landing pages accordingly.

3. Risk mitigation: A/B testing allows you to test new ideas and changes on a small portion of your audience, before rolling them out fully. This can help mitigate the risk of changes that negatively impact your conversion rates.

4. Data-driven decisions: Regular A/B testing provides you with a wealth of data that you can use to make informed decisions about your landing page design and content. This can lead to more effective and efficient marketing strategies.

A/B testing with Contentful

Ready to get started on your A/B testing journey? So are we. You can create a free Contentful account and begin implementing your testing strategy today: check out our testing and personalization solution, Contentful Personalization, and explore a vast Marketplace of partner apps to shape your customer’s content journeys down to the smallest detail. 

Take a tour

Chat with our team

We'll show you how our composable content platform can enhance 1:1 customer connections and drive growth for your business.

Subscribe for updates

Build better digital experiences with Contentful updates direct to your inbox.